Explainers
What ROCE actually measures, and when it lies
Return on capital employed is the first number worth looking at, and the one most easily flattered.
Return on capital employed asks one question: for every rupee the business has tied up, how much does it earn before financing and tax? Operating profit divided by capital employed.
Why not just use ROE?
Return on equity can be manufactured with debt. A business earning a mediocre return on its assets can show a handsome return on equity simply by funding itself with borrowings, because the denominator shrinks. ROCE puts the debt back into the denominator, so it measures the business rather than the financing decision.
Three ways it flatters
- Old assets. A plant bought thirty years ago sits at written-down value. The return looks superb because the denominator is a historical accident, not a replacement cost. Check the age of the asset base before believing a very high figure.
- Capital work in progress. Money already spent on a half-built factory often sits outside capital employed while the profit it will eventually earn is still zero. That is fine. But a company perpetually carrying a large CWIP balance is reporting a return on a denominator that excludes a real, growing pile of shareholder money.
- One good year. A commodity business at the top of its cycle can print a number it will not see again for five years. A single year's ROCE says almost nothing; a ten-year series says a great deal.
A worked example
Suppose a fictional maker of industrial fasteners — call it Rampur Fasteners — reports operating profit of ₹44 crore. Its capital employed is ₹180 crore of net fixed assets plus ₹60 crore of working capital, less ₹40 crore of non-operating cash: ₹200 crore. ROCE is 22%.
Now note that ₹70 crore of that fixed-asset base was commissioned last year and is running at half utilisation. The 22% is being earned on assets that are not yet fully working. That is a reason to look closer, and it could cut either way — the return may rise as utilisation improves, or the new line may never fill. The number alone does not tell you which, which is the entire point of reading further.
Rampur Fasteners does not exist. Every worked example in this library uses a fictional company on purpose. Using a real one would let this page be read as a view on that company, which is not what an explainer is for.
Why this explainer exists. It is the first of the three GAR gates, so every report opens with it.
The monthly letter
One dated letter a month on how the Indian market is priced and what the screens are saying. Free, no stock calls, one-click unsubscribe.